|
ITEM |
BUILDING |
USE |
LOCATION / EQUIP # |
REBUILD VS NEW |
COST |
VENDOR |
CHOICE |
REASONS |
|
1 |
Clinton WTP |
Transfer Pump |
1 |
24% |
$6,186.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
2 |
Clinton WTP |
Transfer Pump Motor |
1 |
73% |
$5,582.00 |
Douglas Pump |
New |
Will allow old unit to be used as spare |
|
3 |
Clinton WTP Intake Building |
Intake Pump |
2 |
|
$31,078.00 |
Douglas Pump |
New |
Raw water intake pump and there is no backup if this is down. |
|
4 |
Clinton WTP Intake Building |
Intake Pump Motor |
2 |
|
$7,594.00 |
JCI |
New |
Raw water intake pump motor and there is no backup if this is down. |
|
5 |
Clinton WTP Pump Gallery |
Central Service Pump |
1 |
93% |
$6,836.00 |
Douglas Pump |
New |
New unit cost is almost same as rebuild of existing equipment, plus will allow for spare unit. |
|
6 |
Clinton WTP Pump Gallery |
Central Service Pump Motor |
1 |
106% |
$2,061.00 |
Douglas Pump |
New |
New unit is cheaper then rebuild of existing equipment. |
|
7 |
Kaw WTP East Shop South |
Central Service Pump |
2 |
48% |
$8,621.00 |
Douglas Pump |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
8 |
Kaw WTP East Shop South |
Central Service Pump Motor |
2 |
102% |
$5,355.00 |
Fairbanks Morse |
New |
New unit is cheaper then rebuild of existing equipment. |
|
9 |
Biosolids Dewatering Building |
Washwater Pump |
1 Press Room |
63% |
$4,705.00 |
Douglas Pump |
New |
Will allow for spare in time of emergency |
|
10 |
Biosolids Dewatering Building |
Washwater Pump Motor |
1 Press Room |
110% |
$414.00 |
Douglas Pump |
New |
New unit is cheaper then rebuild of existing equipment. |
|
11 |
Biosolids Pump Station |
Thickened Sludge Pump |
TSP-2 |
27% |
$4,653.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
12 |
Biosolids Pump Station |
Thickened Sludge Pump Motor |
TSP-2 |
100% |
$2,793.00 |
JCI |
New |
New unit cost is same as rebuild of existing equipment. |
|
13 |
Gas Control Building |
Gas Compressor |
2 |
33% |
$5,335.00 |
Douglas Pump |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
14 |
Gas Control Building |
Gas Compressor Motor |
2 |
100% |
$1,143.00 |
JCI |
New |
New unit cost is same as rebuild of existing equipment. |
|
15 |
Influent Pumping Station |
Raw Sewage Pump |
RSP-4-2 |
23% |
$9,355.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
16 |
Influent Pumping Station |
Raw Sewage Pump Motor |
RSP-4-2 |
11% |
$4,960.00 |
JCI |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
17 |
North Final Buidling |
Waste Pump |
WASP-1 |
29% |
$4,372.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
18 |
North Final Buidling |
Waste Pump Motor |
WASP-1 |
100% |
$1,865.00 |
JCI |
New |
New unit cost is same as rebuild of existing equipment. |
|
19 |
PS 13 2210 East 23rd |
15-2039 |
1 |
43% |
$3,319.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
20 |
PS 23 3003 O'Connell Drive |
|
1 |
63% |
$3,271.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
21 |
PS 27 3099 Sherwood Drive |
14-1595 |
2 |
44% |
$3,453.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
22 |
PS 31 2838 Meadow Drive |
6603885 |
1 |
39% |
$3,453.00 |
Letts Van Kirk |
Rebuild |
Most economical to rebuild. |
|
|
|
|
|
Total |
$126,404.00 |
|
|
|
|
|
Note: On item 7 the low bid from Letts, Van Kirk was unable to perform certified performance testing before reinstalling this pump so their bid was rejected. |
|||||||
|
|
Highlighted indicates low bid |
|||||||